from clarindavine (69%) on August 28th, 2007 (8 months ago)

Fishers in the City, 58 Thistle Street, EH2 1EN, Edinburgh

CHARMINGLY OLD FASHIONED & REASSURINGLY EXPENSIVE

After hearing many good things about this restaurant my partner took me here earlier in the year for our anniversary - we were not disapointed.

The restaurant is hidden away on Thistle Street and is full of old fashioned charm. It is split on two levels which makes for a cosier and private atmosphere. Although full it did not seem over crowded. The cliental as far as I could tell were all quite well to do and we seemed to be some of the youngest diners there (we are in our late twenties). However, don't let this put you off the food was lovely and the service friendly and efficient.

The menu though not extensive was well thought out and obviously heavily based around seasonal fish. The food was fresh, of good quality and definitely all home made - even the dessert, which is sadly often a rarity these days.

Yes, it is expensive but I think certainly worth it for a treat or special occasion. It cost us just under £90 for two: one starter, two mains, two desserts, one lager, one bottle of wine (mid-price) and a bottle of water. While I wouldn't eat here regularly (our budget doesn't stretch that far!) I would certainly recommend it for a special occasion or meal out with older relatives - you know whatever you get is going to be good - and you know you aren't going to be bothered by noisy co-diners.

I would definitely recommend Fishers, although make sure you reserve in advance as it gets booked up early.

Useful?Useful(+2) Agree?I agree(+2) Funny?Ha ha!(0) Report?Spam

Sign up or log in to moderate this review

from rachybaby (66%) on August 30th, 2007 (8 months ago)

Fishers in the City, 58 Thistle Street, EH2 1EN, Edinburgh

The Seabass was fantastic! Easily the best fish restaurant in Edinburgh.

Useful?Useful(-2) Agree?I agree(0) Funny?Ha ha!(0) Report?Spam

Sign up or log in to moderate this review

from eveybaby (37%) on April 16th, 2008 (1 month ago)

Fishers in the City, 58 Thistle Street, EH2 1EN, Edinburgh

Have visited this restaurant twice - overall very good.

On my last visit there I noticed that there were no vegetarian main courses (not that it affected me) but as I have vegetarian friends I happened to notice this. Also, the menu seemed to change before we had ordered (many of the things on the menu were either out of stock or had been altered) - the waitress had to come back THREE times to notify us of changes - even after I had decided what to order. This was very annoying. However she was very polite and apologetic. The food which I did order was excellent. I probably would have eaten anything off the menu so the changes to the menu didn't really affect me that much! Wine was great too. I wasn't paying (phewf) - but it's definitely more of a restaurant to go to for a special occasion.

Useful?Useful(+2) Agree?I agree(0) Funny?Ha ha!(0) Report?Spam

Sign up or log in to moderate this review

from julieadair (30%) on March 10th, 2008 (2 months ago)

Fishers in the City, 58 Thistle Street, EH2 1EN, Edinburgh

I love this restaurant - great atmosphere, wonderful service and the fish is amazing. What I love, too, is that you can have a glass of wine (their Muscadet is excellent) and eat at the bar as a 'drop-in'.

Useful?Useful(+2) Agree?I agree(0) Funny?Ha ha!(0) Report?Spam

Sign up or log in to moderate this review

from Mike and Lynne (20%) on April 25th, 2008 (3 weeks ago)

Fishers in the City, 58 Thistle Street, EH2 1EN, Edinburgh

Could not fault this restaurant. Service is attentive but not overbearing reflecting the relaxed atmosphere. Food is excellent, fish soup was simply stunning, main courses - fish pie and Stonebass were again faultless. Pudding was a chocolate crepe filled with mascarpone and morello cherries, again perfect not oversweet and aided by some fresh tangy raspberries. Very good wine lst with house wines starting at £13.95. Bill came to £73, excellent value for money. Highly recommend.

Useful?Useful(+1) Agree?I agree(0) Funny?Ha ha!(0) Report?Spam

Sign up or log in to moderate this review